Cooperatives and other fields of law
No. 4 (2022)
THE TAXATION OF CO-OPERATIVES’ INCOME: ANALYSIS OF ITS RATIONALE
-
Submitted
-
August 22 2025
-
Published
-
22-08-2025
Abstract
In this paper we address the issue of taxation of cooperatives’ income. Cooperatives traditionallyreceive a specific tax treatment distinct from that given to companies. In general terms, thatspecific cooperative tax regime is apparently more favorable when compared to the one applied to companies. A tradition of granting cooperatives a favorable taxrelief-based tax regime is widely extended, being noticeable inall Western European Countriesandin the Northern American countries (USA and Canada). This paper seeks to lay down some conceptual basis on which the issue ought to beanalyzed, with aspecial emphasis on the definition of what is to be treated as cooperative income for tax purposes and the rationale for afavorable cooperative tax regime.
References
- AGUIAR, Nina(2015). Princípios cooperativos e benefícios fiscais. CIRIEC-España Revista Jurídica, 27, pp. 429-458.
View in Google Scholar
- AGUIAR, N. (2016).O Problema da Tributação do Rendimento dasCooperativas –reflexão a partir do direito português.Revista Cooperativismoe Economía Social, 38, pp. 163-190.
View in Google Scholar
- ALGUACIL, Maria (2010). Condicionantes del régimende ayudas de estado en la fiscalidad de las cooperativas. Revista de Economía Pública, Social y Cooperativa, 69, pp. 27-52.BAARDA, James (2007). Cooperatives and IncomeTax Principles. Little Rock: University of Arkansas.
View in Google Scholar
- BANDEIRA, Ana, MEIRA, Deolinda &ALVES, Vera (2017).Los diferentes tipos de resultados en las cooperativas portuguesas. Unestudio de caso múltiple. REVESCO-Revista de estudios cooperativos, 123, pp.37-63.
View in Google Scholar
- BELLO, Dogarawa (2005). The Role of Cooperative Societies in Economic Development. MPRA -Munich Personal RePEc Archive, Papernr. 23161.
View in Google Scholar
- CABALEIRO, Maria (2000). El excedente de la sociedad cooperativa, especial referencia a la Ley 5/1998 de Cooperativas de Galicia
View in Google Scholar
- REVESCO-Revista de estudios cooperativos, 72, pp. 33-50.
View in Google Scholar
- CHAMBERS, E. (1947) Should the earnings of co-operative associations bemade subject to the federal income tax? British Columbia: University of British Columbia.
View in Google Scholar
- COLE, George(1944). Acentury of co-operation. Manchester, George Allen And Unwin Ltd.
View in Google Scholar
- FAJARDO, Isabel-Gemma (1992). La gestión económica de la cooperativa: Responsabilidad de los sócios. Valencia: Universidad de Valencia.
View in Google Scholar
- FICI, Antonio (2013). “An Introduction to cooperative law”, inD. CRACOGNA, A. FICI & H. HENRY (eds.). International Handbook of Cooperative Law, Springer: Berlin. FICI, Antonio (2015). La Función social de las cooperativas: Notas de derecho comparado. REVESCO 117, pp. 77-98.
View in Google Scholar
- FREDERICK, Donald (2005). Income tax treatment of cooperatives: Patronage Refunds and other Income Issues, Cooperative Information Report 44, Part 2, Washigton: USDA Rural Development.
View in Google Scholar
- GIORGI, Maurizio, & VACIAGO, Giuzeppe (2011). Le società cooperative. Tipi di cooperative. Strumentidi tutela. Aspetti civili, concorsuali, tributari e penali. Padua: CEDAM.
View in Google Scholar
- HANDSCHIN, Hans (1950). Die Besteuerung der Genossenschaften. Wohnen, 25, pp. 234-237.HENRY, Hagen (2005). Guidelines for cooperatives legislation,2. ed. Geneva, ILO –International Labour Organization.
View in Google Scholar
- HENRY, Hagen (2012). Guidelines for cooperation legislation. 3. ed. Geneva: ILO –International Labour Organization. Hinojosa, Juan (2010). Fiscalidad y financiación de las cooperativas: ¿A qué juegala Unión Europea?,Revista de Economía Pública, Social y Cooperativa, 69, pp. 73-89.
View in Google Scholar
- LLOBREGAT, Maria (1989). El principio de mutualidade y su incidência sobre el regímen jurídico-economico de las sociedades cooperativas. Alicante, Universidad de Alicante.
View in Google Scholar
- MAGILL, Roswell (1960). The Exemption of Cooperativesfrom Income Taxation, Montana Law Review, 21,pp. 155-167.
View in Google Scholar
- MEIRA, Deolinda (2012a). Revisitando o problema da distinção entre excedente cooperativo e lucro societário.Proceedings of the 2ndCongress ofCorporate Law. Coimbra: Almedina.
View in Google Scholar
- MEIRA, Deolinda (2012b). “As Operações com terceiros no direito cooperativo português”, in D. MEIRA (coord.), Jurisprudência cooperativa comentada. Lisboa: INCM –Imprensa Nacional Casa da Moeda.
View in Google Scholar
- MEIRA, Deolinda (2015). “O regime da distribuição de resultadosnas cooperativas de crédito em Portugal. Uma análise crítica”. Boletín de la Asociación Internacional de Derecho Cooperativo, 49.
View in Google Scholar
- MEIRA, Deolinda & RAMOS, Elisabete (2014). Governação e regime económico das cooperativas -Estado da arte e linhas de reforma. Porto: Vida Económica.
View in Google Scholar
- MUNKNER, Hans-H. (2018). Legal Frameworkanalysis. National Report: Germany.
View in Google Scholar
- ICA-EU Partnership, Cooperatives Europe.MUSGRAVE, Richard (1990). Horizontal equity, once more. National Tax Journal, Vol. 43, 2 (June, 1990), pp 113-122.
View in Google Scholar
- PACKEL, Israel (1941). Cooperatives and the Income Tax. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 137, pp. 137-155.
View in Google Scholar
- PEPE, Francesco (2009). La fiscalità delle cooperative, Riparto dei carichi pubblici e scopo mutualistico, Mian: Giuffrè Editore.
View in Google Scholar
- PIGOU, Arthur C. (1920). Cooperative societies and income tax.The Economic Journal, Vol. 30, 118 (Jun 1920), pp. 156-162.
View in Google Scholar
- TORRES, Carlos (2013). “Peru”, inD. CRACOGNA, A. FICI & H. HENRY (eds.). International Handbook of Cooperative Law, Springer: Berlin.
View in Google Scholar
- VARGAS, Carlos. (2006) La actividad cooperarativizada y las relaciones dela cooperativa com sus sócios y com terceros Navarra: Editorial Aranzadi.
View in Google Scholar
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.